Judgment

Languages: 中文 | English | Español | 日本語 | 한국어 | Tiếng Việt | ไทย | Русский

📖 Detailed Explanation

In foreign trade terminology, 'Judgment' does not refer to a court ruling in an ordinary commercial dispute, but specifically to the final decision made by the issuing bank on whether the documents comply in a letter of credit transaction. The ICC Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP600) stipulates that the issuing bank shall, within a maximum of five banking days following the day of receipt of the documents, examine them on the basis of the documents alone and independently make a 'judgment' to accept or refuse the documents. This judgment is final and directly determines whether the beneficiary can obtain payment. Usage scenarios include: the issuing bank issues a notice of refusal after examining documents, the nominated bank and the issuing bank dispute discrepancies, or the beneficiary requests the issuing bank to reconsider its refusal decision. Points to note: the judgment must state all discrepancies in a single notice, otherwise the issuing bank will lose its right to refuse; the judgment must be sent by telecommunication or in writing and state the disposal of the documents. Difference from other terms: it is different from a court judgment and also different from an arbitral award; it is a professional document examination conclusion of a bank under a letter of credit.

📝 Examples

1. After receiving the full set of documents submitted by the beneficiary, the issuing bank, upon examination, found that the date of the bill of lading was later than the latest shipment date stipulated in the letter of credit, and therefore made a judgment of refusal and listed this discrepancy in a single notice. (Note: The issuing bank exercises its document examination right and makes a refusal decision.) 2. The beneficiary objected to the issuing bank's judgment of refusal, arguing that although the date of the bill of lading was later, it complied with Article 20 of UCP600 regarding the date of shipment, and requested the issuing bank to re-examine and revoke the judgment. (Note: The beneficiary's dispute over and remedy against the bank's judgment.)

💡 Foreign Trade Tips

📧 Use Business Email Helper