The concept of 'environmental determinism' has long been a contentious issue in geography. Early proponents argued that human activities and societal development were largely dictated by climatic and geographical conditions. However, this perspective was criticized for oversimplifying complex human-environment interactions and for its potential to justify colonialism. Modern scholarship, such as that by Jared Diamond, has revived interest in the role of geography in shaping historical outcomes, but with more nuance. Diamond posits that geographical factors, such as the availability of domesticable species and the orientation of continental axes, influenced the uneven development of civilizations. Yet, he acknowledges that these factors are not deterministic but rather provide a framework within which human agency and cultural choices operate. Thus, contemporary environmental geography emphasizes a reciprocal relationship, where humans modify their environment while being influenced by it, rejecting both strict determinism and the idea that environment has no impact at all.
❓ Según el pasaje, ¿cuál es la principal diferencia entre el determinismo ambiental temprano y la erudición moderna como la de Jared Diamond?
A. El determinismo temprano ignoró por completo el clima, mientras que Diamond se centra en el clima.
B. La visión de Diamond es más matizada, al considerar la agencia humana, mientras que el determinismo temprano era excesivamente simplista.
C. La erudición moderna rechaza por completo cualquier influencia de la geografía en las sociedades humanas.
D. El determinismo temprano se basaba en evidencia empírica, mientras que el trabajo de Diamond es puramente teórico.
✅ 正确答案
Diamond's view is more nuanced, considering human agency, whereas early determinism was overly simplistic.
IELTS Reading Tips
Skim the questions first, underline keywords, then locate in the passage
Watch for paraphrasing; correct answers are often reworded
Be wary of absolute statements (all, always, never) — usually wrong
Pay attention to content after transition words (however, but, yet)
Manage time: about 20 minutes per passage; skip difficult questions first