Viết tích hợp TOEFL

📖 Đoạn văn

The extinction of the passenger pigeon, once the most abundant bird in North America, is often attributed to overhunting by humans in the 19th century. However, a closer examination of the ecological and genetic evidence suggests that the species' demise was not solely due to human predation but was significantly driven by intrinsic biological factors. First, the passenger pigeon exhibited extreme population fluctuations, with massive irruptions followed by dramatic crashes. These natural boom-and-bust cycles, observed before heavy human hunting, indicate that the species was inherently vulnerable to sudden population collapses, possibly due to food scarcity or disease. Second, genetic analyses of museum specimens reveal that the passenger pigeon had remarkably low genetic diversity, despite its enormous population size. This lack of variation would have made the species less adaptable to environmental changes, increasing the risk of extinction when conditions shifted. Third, the passenger pigeon's reproductive strategy was highly dependent on large, dense nesting colonies. This social behavior, while effective in overwhelming predators, became a liability when populations declined, as the birds required a critical mass to breed successfully. Once numbers fell below a threshold, reproduction rates plummeted, accelerating the decline.

🎧 Bài giảng

The professor challenges the reading's claim that the passenger pigeon's extinction was primarily due to natural biological factors. While acknowledging that the species had population fluctuations, the professor argues that these cycles were not extreme enough to cause extinction without human interference. Historical records show that the pigeon populations always rebounded after natural crashes, and the final decline in the 1870s-1890s coincided exactly with the peak of commercial hunting. Regarding genetic diversity, the professor points out that recent genomic studies, contrary to the reading, found that the passenger pigeon actually possessed adaptive genetic variation in genes related to immune response and metabolism. This suggests the species was not as genetically fragile as claimed. Moreover, low genetic diversity is common in many thriving species today, such as cheetahs, so it alone cannot explain extinction. Finally, the professor refutes the reproductive threshold argument. Historical accounts describe that even small flocks, as few as a few hundred birds, were observed successfully breeding in captivity and in the wild. The real cause of reproductive failure was not a lack of numbers but the disruption of nesting sites by hunters, who destroyed eggs and chicks while harvesting adults. Thus, human activities, not biology, were the decisive factor.