TOEFL 통합 작문

📖 읽기 지문

The decline of the honeybee population, known as colony collapse disorder (CCD), has been widely attributed to the use of neonicotinoid pesticides. However, a closer examination suggests that neonicotinoids are not the primary cause. First, field studies show that bees exposed to neonicotinoids at real-world concentrations do not exhibit significant mortality or colony failure. For example, a large-scale study in Canada found no correlation between neonicotinoid residues in hive wax and colony loss rates. Second, CCD outbreaks often occur in regions where neonicotinoid use is low, such as parts of Australia, while areas with high usage, like the United States, do not always have higher CCD rates. This geographic mismatch undermines the pesticide hypothesis. Third, alternative factors, such as the parasitic Varroa mite and associated viruses, better explain CCD patterns. Colonies infested with Varroa mites show a characteristic symptom: worker bees abandon the hive, leaving the queen and brood behind—exactly the signature of CCD. In contrast, pesticide exposure typically causes immediate bee death within the hive, not abandonment. Therefore, while neonicotinoids may pose some risk, they are not the main driver of CCD; instead, biological stressors like Varroa mites are more plausible culprits.

🎧 듣기 강의

The reading's argument that neonicotinoids are not the primary cause of CCD is flawed. First, the Canadian study mentioned actually measured residue levels in wax, but it did not assess acute exposure during foraging. Bees in the field encounter neonicotinoids in nectar and pollen, which can impair their navigation and foraging behavior, leading to colony weakening over time—even if adult bees do not die immediately. Such sublethal effects are well documented and can cause colony collapse indirectly. Second, the geographic argument is misleading. Australia does have CCD-like symptoms, but its CCD rates are lower because Varroa mites are absent there; however, this does not rule out pesticides, as Australian bees may be exposed to different pesticide mixtures. In the United States, CCD is more prevalent in agricultural areas with high neonicotinoid use, and recent meta-analyses show a significant positive correlation between neonicotinoid application and CCD incidence when controlling for mite levels. Third, the reading incorrectly separates mites and pesticides. Research shows that neonicotinoid exposure weakens bees' immune systems, making them more susceptible to Varroa mites and viruses. In fact, colonies exposed to both neonicotinoids and mites collapse at higher rates than those with mites alone. Thus, neonicotinoids act as a synergistic factor, not an alternative, and they play a critical role in triggering CCD by exacerbating the effects of biological stressors.