托福综合写作

📖 阅读文章

The extinction of the woolly mammoth (Mammuthus primigenius) at the end of the Pleistocene has long been debated. While some scientists argue that human hunting was the primary cause, others propose that climate change or a combination of factors drove their demise. This passage examines three key pieces of evidence supporting the overhunting hypothesis. First, archaeological sites across North America and Eurasia show a clear temporal overlap between the arrival of human populations and the decline of mammoth populations. For instance, at the Clovis sites in North America, dated to approximately 13,000 years ago, mammoth bones have been found alongside distinctive spear points, suggesting active hunting. Second, the life history traits of mammoths—such as a long gestation period and extended parental care—made them particularly vulnerable to hunting pressure. Unlike smaller, faster-reproducing species, mammoths would have required decades to recover from even modest levels of human predation. Third, the rapid extinction of mammoths on isolated islands, such as Wrangel Island, correlates with the first evidence of human settlement on those islands, not with significant climate shifts. This pattern strongly implies that human activity, not environmental change, was the decisive factor.

🎧 听力讲座

The lecture challenges the overhunting hypothesis presented in the reading. While the professor acknowledges that humans did hunt mammoths, she argues that the evidence is far from conclusive and that climate change offers a more plausible explanation. First, the temporal overlap between human arrival and mammoth decline does not prove causation. In many regions, mammoth populations had already begun to decline thousands of years before humans arrived, as indicated by genetic and fossil records. For example, in Beringia, mammoth numbers dropped significantly during the Last Glacial Maximum, well before the first human migrants crossed the land bridge. Second, the reading’s argument about life history traits is misleading. While mammoths did have long gestation periods, they also had low natural mortality rates among adults, which could have sustained populations even under moderate hunting. Moreover, modern elephants, which have similar traits, have been shown to tolerate some hunting pressure without immediate collapse. Third, the island extinction cases are not as clear-cut as the reading suggests. On Wrangel Island, mammoths persisted for thousands of years after human arrival, and their extinction coincided with a period of rapid environmental change, including shrinking vegetation and altered freshwater sources. Thus, the lecture concludes that climate change, not human hunting, was the primary driver of mammoth extinction.