托福综合写作

📖 阅读文章

The extinction of the megafauna—large animals such as mammoths, giant sloths, and saber-toothed cats—at the end of the Pleistocene epoch has long puzzled scientists. While many hypotheses exist, the most widely accepted explanation is overhunting by early humans. This theory, known as the 'Pleistocene overkill hypothesis,' argues that human hunters, armed with advanced tools and cooperative strategies, drove these animals to extinction shortly after their arrival in new territories. First, archaeological evidence supports this claim: kill sites with butchered megafauna remains coincide with human expansion across continents, such as the Clovis culture in North America. Second, the timing of extinctions aligns with human migration patterns; in New Zealand, for example, the moa disappeared within a century of Polynesian settlement. Third, megafauna exhibited life-history traits—such as long gestation periods and low reproductive rates—that made them highly vulnerable to even modest levels of hunting pressure. Together, these points suggest that human predation was the primary driver of megafaunal extinction, rather than climate change or other natural causes.

🎧 听力讲座

The reading's overkill hypothesis is appealing, but it fails to account for several critical lines of evidence. First, the archaeological record is not as clear-cut as it suggests. Many purported kill sites lack definitive proof of human hunting, such as cut marks or projectile points embedded in bones. In some cases, the megafauna bones show signs of scavenging, not active predation, meaning humans may have merely fed on animals that died from other causes. Second, the timing argument is flawed. In many regions, such as Australia and the Americas, megafaunal extinctions occurred well before or after human arrival, with gaps of thousands of years. This inconsistency undermines the direct causal link. Third, the vulnerability of megafauna to hunting is overstated. Modern examples, like elephants and rhinos, have coexisted with human hunters for millennia without extinction, suggesting that reproductive rates alone do not determine survival. More importantly, climate fluctuations during the Pleistocene were severe and rapid, and many megafauna species had survived previous glacial cycles but not the one coinciding with their demise—a pattern better explained by habitat loss and vegetation changes. Therefore, the lecture argues that climate change, not human overhunting, was the more likely primary cause.