The concept of 'environmental determinism' posits that human activities and societal development are predominantly shaped by climatic and geographical conditions. This theory, popular in the 19th and early 20th centuries, argued that temperate climates fostered industriousness and technological innovation, while tropical regions, due to their heat and humidity, were associated with lethargy and limited progress. However, modern geographical scholarship has largely rejected this deterministic view, emphasizing instead the role of human agency, cultural values, and historical contingencies. Critics point to examples such as the advanced civilizations of the Maya and Inca in tropical and mountainous environments, which flourished despite adverse conditions. Contemporary research advocates for a more nuanced 'possibilism' framework, wherein the environment offers a set of constraints and opportunities, but human choices and cultural adaptations ultimately determine outcomes. This shift reflects a broader academic trend toward recognizing complexity and rejecting simplistic causal explanations in social science.
❓ 根据文章所述,现代学者拒绝环境决定论的主要原因是什么?
A. A. 它过度强调了人类能动性在塑造社会中的作用。
B. B. 它未能解释在恶劣环境中存在先进文明的例子。
C. C. 它忽视了气候对农业生产力的影响。
D. D. 它仅基于19世纪的过时数据。
✅ 正确答案
B. It fails to account for examples of advanced civilizations in challenging environments.